The issue of Canada joining the United States as its 51st state cropped up anew with a jest from President-elect Donald Trump during a dinner with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. The remark has gone viral, made in the context of the announced tariffs against Canadian products by Trump, hence a significant mill of discussions on what that would mean.
The context of Trump’s comment
With a one dinner conversation at Mar-a-Lago, Trump quipped that if Canada couldn’t hold up to the economic pressures he might slap 25% tariffs on their products as discussed in this article, Trump threatens to impose sweeping new tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China – These are the items that will suffer the most when he…, maybe it should just become the 51st state. Trudeau had expressed how terrible the tariffs would be to Canada’s economy, and so when he got the quip about statehood being an antidote to economic suffering, it elicited nervous laughter around the room-one that mixed disbelief and discomfort.
This was not entirely a new comment by Trump, but he has said similar jokes previously. This latest iteration, however, came when the relationship between the United States and Canada was being called into question as a result of some pretty strong tensions in trade and economics regarding his tariff proposals. Some economists have suggested that such tariffs threaten to throw Canada into a recession and erode the value of its currency, lending gravity to Trump’s jest.
Historical precedents and political implications
The notion of Canada becoming a state of the United States is an idea rooted in history, often within discourses on American expansionism and manifest destiny. Such ideas, although taken as humor or hyperbole, reflect deeper anxieties on the nature of U.S.-Canada relations. The Canadian nationalists fear that any serious discussion about statehood erodes Canadian sovereignty and identity.
In response, Canadian officials have largely minimized the weight of the remark. A senior minister present at the dinner described Trump’s suggestion as a joke, more at rattling Canadian sensibilities than a genuine proposal. This shows a diplomatic way of keeping one’s cool in the face of rhetoric that can be deemed destabilizing.
Economic considerations
With Trump’s tariffs, the economic implications for Canada are huge. With roughly 77% of Canadian exports leaving for the U.S., any rise in tariffs could lead to severe repercussions for key industries: energy, automotive, and agriculture. Without reciprocal measures taken by Canada, economists have warned these tariffs could result in zero growth and higher inflation within Canada.
Besides, if Canada became a state, its economic landscape would change altogether. The advantages and disadvantages of integration into the U.S. economy could go either way. While it may provide bigger markets and federal support, it could also mean loss of autonomy to run economic policies and regulations.
Public sentiment and national identity
Public sentiment in Canada about the idea of becoming a U.S. state is predominantly adverse. Canadians pride themselves on their national identity, quite different from that of their southern neighbor. The concept of statehood raises several fears related to cultural dilution and loss of sovereignty.
This does, however, suggest through the polling data that a majority of Canadians would like to remain independent of America. Events in history also prove this, showcasing just how strong the opposition was when annexation was tried and how eager Canadians were to preserve their political and cultural identities.
Read more: Where will it snow in the United States on Thanksgiving Day? The weather forecast with the states that will have snow on November 28th
Read more: What is the Kennedy family tree, what is Robert’s link to JFK and how many of the former president’s children are still alive?
