After eight years of loyalty to Costco and only Costco, the Thompson family finally crossed over into Sam’s Club territory in 2023 with a promotional $20 membership. Their heart belongs to the quality and brand trust of Costco, but they strategically renewed both memberships through 2025, based on pragmatic comparisons of pricing, product availability, and logistical realities. Here’s how their dual-membership experiment reshaped their bulk shopping strategy.
Membership economics: Crunching the numbers
Thompson’s $180 annual spend covers:
- Costco Executive Membership: $130 (2% cashback up to $1,000)
- Sam’s Club Plus Membership: $50 (2% cashback up to $500)
Their 2024 spending breakdown shows why both cards keep humming:
| Category | Costco Spend | Sam’s Spend | Key Difference |
| Gasoline | $1,200 | $1,800 | Sam’s $0.12/gal cheaper near home |
| Organic Produce | $3,400 | $760 | Costco’s sealed packaging preferred |
| Paper Goods | $220 | $480 | Member’s Mark 18% cheaper than Kirkland |
| Electronics | $1,150 | $0 | Costco’s extended warranties valued |
The Executive membership paid $228 cashback versus Sam’s $156 – but combined savings overcame both fees by March 2024.
Product availability: Complementary inventories
Costco’s irreplaceables
- Kirkland organic almond butter ($6.99/28oz)
- Executive-exclusive vacation packages
- $4.99 rotisserie chickens (loss leader)
Sam’s Club standouts
- Member’s Mark biodegradable plates ($12.97/120ct)
- Local favorite BBQ sauce unavailable at Costco
- Scan & Go app enabled 74% faster checkouts
The family developed hybrid shopping patterns:
1. Monthly Costco runs:
– Bulk organic staples
– Appliance purchases
– Prescription refills
2. Sam’s weekly trips:
– Party supplies on short notice
– Fill-ups
– Variety snack packs
Location dynamics: The 15-mile decider
Since Sam’s Club is only 4 miles from the Thompson home compared to Costco’s 19-mile location, they saved:
- Fuel annual cost: $312 (78 fewer gallons used)
- Time saved: 104 hours less driving per year
This proximity proved critical for:
- Emergency runs for diapers/baby formula
- Quick floral purchases for school events
- Prescription pickups during busy weeks
Quality vs. Convenience tradeoffs
Costco advantages
- 93% satisfaction rate on major appliances
- Healthier prepared meals (avg. 480mg sodium vs Sam’s 720mg)
- Premium wine selection (22+ Silver Medal winners)
Sam’s Club compromises
- 38% of produce required in-store inspection for freshness
- Limited organic snack options
- No executive concierge services
“We’ll drive to Costco for important purchases, but Sam’s gets our ‘oh crap’ money when time matters.”
Cashback optimization strategy
By optimizing purchase allocation:
- Costco: High-margin categories (electronics, organic)
- Sam’s Club: High-frequency essentials (gas, cleaning supplies)
They maximized combined rewards:
TotalCashback=(0.02×$14,200
Costco)+(0.02×$7,800
Sam’s)
=$284+$156=$440
This offset 244% of their combined membership fees – a top renewal driver.
The verdict for why both stay
Four factors sealed dual membership:
- Gas price arbitrage: Sam’s saved $18/month despite lower cashback
- Emergency access: 8pm Sam’s runs vs Costco’s 8:30pm close 1
- Complementary brands: 23 products only available at one chain
- App ecosystem: Scan & Go (Sam’s) vs Costco’s superior inventory alerts
As Mrs. Thompson notes:
“It’s like having a sports car and pickup truck – each excels where the other struggles. We’ll keep both until one fundamentally changes.”
Their experience has proved that in the warehouse club wars, strategic pluralism often beats brand loyalty. For families trying to balance aspirations for quality with real-world constraints, dual membership is not only viable, it’s mathematically advantageous if managed carefully.
Read more: Honda recalls nearly 295K Honda, Acura vehicles for risk of engine stall, power loss – These are the models and model years affected
Read more: Good news as major retailer exits bankruptcy, losing only two stores
